From Rootsweb.com: "McCaig Cemetery is on Mountain Mills Road in Colbert County actually Barton Alabama. It is located in a small patch of woods between two houses right down the street from Mt Springs Cemetery. There is a survey of the cemetery. Only a few graves, most of them unmarked now, but were at one time."
Recently we visited the McCaig Cemetery with someone from the Alabama Cemetery Preservation Alliance, who said that it almost certainly contains many graves, even though it only has a handful of modern headstones. See all those rocks "lying around"? Please leave them alone. Each one was carefully placed to help family members remember who's buried where.