(Remember that the direction at the end of the CR is for location and not direction. ie. a road running North and South will have an E or W at the end).
We were going North on CR3095 E, just south of Seatonville; when we found CR1390 N. If you followed the road North you would intersect Route 6. CR1390 N only goes West and there is a small house on the Northwest corner. (You can see the farmhouse from the main road too). It looks like you are going onto a private road.
Turn left (West) at CR3095 E and CR1390 N
Turn right just after the utility pole and proceed down the grass 'lane.' Follow the lane down about 1/4 mile and the gate to the cemetery is on the right.
A large dumpster and 2 burn barrels were present the day we were there. You would pass those on the right as you made your turn onto the lane. (If you follow the road around to the left you will come to the farmhouse of the man who is the Ottville Cemetery caretaker).
This is a very old cemetery. Most of the graves are from the 1800's. Many of the graves you can't read. The caretaker keeps good care of the cemetery. But there are no signs anywhere that guide you to the cemetery.